Perhaps the most common objection to the Faith is that if God is all-powerful and all-holy, there should be no such thing as evil. This objection is philosophically complicated in the extreme, and I don’t think anyone has been able to fully address this, although I have come up with a possible partial explanation through much consideration of the nature of cause and effect and of that which has often been referred to as “free will.” It is also possible to point out that God’s glory and character are more clearly manifested in a fallen world than in an unfallen one and that evil has no meaning apart from an infinite Standard of good. If you want to discuss abstruse philosophical questions with me, I’d be glad to try to explain my take, but I’m not going to do that here. My purpose in writing today is not to confuse anyone with the confused and confusing products of my mind, for although intellectual discussions are necessary to satisfy the gray matter of those prone to think too hard, they rarely if ever give anyone peace.
Perhaps the most common stumbling block over which people fall and thus fall away from the faith or are hardened to it is the grim reality of suffering and death. Countless people have experienced a tragedy and subsequently been unable to believe in God’s love, goodness, justice, sovereignty, or wisdom; in many cases people have been left rejecting even the existence of God. It is not wrong to explain to such a person that God has a plan and that His ways are higher than our ways. It is not wrong to point out that bad things do not happen to good people since there are no such people. It is not wrong to say that a person who stumbles upon experiencing a personal tragedy has clearly not thought through the faith before, or that person would have realized that such things happen often and to all. Yet these assertions tend to be unsatisfying to the sorrowing soul.
Many people object to the idea of Hell. It’s easy to see why. Certainly, it is one of the least pleasant Christian doctrines. Even God does not like this doctrine. “‘Do I take any pleasure in the death of the wicked?’ Declares the Sovereign LORD. ‘Rather, am I not pleased when they turn from their ways and live?’” (Ezekiel 18:23) Yet the word of God is clear that He will eternally condemn all do not kiss the Son. The glory of God is infinite; having offended against the infinite, our punishment must likewise be insufferable and unending. Knowing this, we must acknowledge the justice of God, but this too may fail to set the soul at rest.
All this can be answered intellectually, at least to some extent, and all this should be answered intellectually because Christianity is a faith fundamentally rooted in absolute truth. We cannot fully grasp all truth and should not pretend to do so, but all of these things are true and have true explanations, and we are to love the LORD with all our minds. However, the frequent disconnect between the mind and heart is answered in the cross. Though that to which the mind assents may yet be revolted against by the heart, Christ Himself bore our burdens in such a way as to speak directly to our hearts and assure us that even if the way things are does not make perfect sense, the LORD is still God, and His word still stands.
To those who question the justice of Hell, look and see that in order for any to be brought near to God, He Himself had to suffer their penalty. For the cup which I held, that each redeemed sinner held, the cup of God’s wrath, the Son took and drank. He begged the Father to find another way, but there was none. So He drank. He became sin. He became a curse. He was forsaken by the Father. And is it not clear that in bearing more sin than any human, He suffered more than any human? Could we possibly fault God for punishing sin in this way when He was willing to endure such wrath Himself? Is it not clear that were there another way to redeem mankind, He surely would have taken it?
For those who have experienced such hurt and loss that it is hard to imagine a sovereign God of love, see in the cross the ultimate expression of love. See that no man has greater love than to lay down His life for His friends. See that to take your sin upon Himself would not have been possible were not His love extraordinary. Know that He felt the very griefs that you now feel. Know that He sympathizes with you in every way – by experience. Understand that all this was part of a perfect plan that through the cross will result in infinite good. Understand that by trusting in Him, your night will end in everlasting dawn, even as it did for Him. For He offered one sacrifice – Himself – and sat down at the right hand of God; so too, through His death, you may offer yourself once as a living sacrifice no matter what that costs and afterward enjoy God’s glory for eternity. You have never had a night as dark as that morning was for Jesus, and His night ended forever; so too can yours.
And for those who question how a holy God can exist in the same universe as evil, see in His death proof positive that He exists and that He hates evil. See too that in His death He has already established the end of history – the destruction of all evil. See God’s absolute hatred of evil in that it was necessary for the Father to crush the Son in order for the Spirit to bring us who know only evil into fellowship with the triune God. See the reality of evil in the reality of Christ’s suffering. See the reality of God in Christ Himself – who triumphing over death and evil came down from the cross and up from the grave and left our sin and our condemnation still hanging there. See Him who was able to lay down His life, take it up again, and give it out freely. To believe this is to know the true God – and eternal life. See the darkness that did not come from an eclipse, the earthquake that tore the temple’s thick veil, and the resurrected Jesus, and do not be unbelieving but believing.
I’m still not quite done; the resurrection deserves its own meditation.
"Moist with one drop of Thy blood, my dry soul
Shall—though she now be in extreme degree
Too stony hard, and yet too fleshly—be
Freed by that drop, from being starved, hard or foul,
And life by this death abled shall control
Death, whom Thy death slew; nor shall to me
Fear of first or last death bring misery,
If in thy life-book my name thou enroll.
Flesh in that long sleep is not putrified, But made that there, of which, and for which it was;
Nor can by other means be glorified.
May then sin's sleep and death soon from me pass,
That waked from both, I again risen may
Salute the last and everlasting day."